Skip to content

Last updated

Reviewed against published research RSS

Makeup

What "Non-Comedogenic" Means on Makeup Labels

What a non-comedogenic claim on makeup means, how comedogenicity is tested, why ingredient lists can mislead, and how to wear makeup with acne-prone skin.

A palette of eight face powder shades and a makeup brush on a grey surface
Fig. 1 A non-comedogenic label may rest on human patch tests, clinical trials or older rabbit ear data. Labels rarely say which. Photograph: Kelly Sikkema / Unsplash

"Non-comedogenic" appears on foundations, concealers, primers and sunscreens, usually as a reassurance for people with acne-prone skin. Dermatologists do recommend looking for it. But the word has a history, and the way products earn it is less standardized than many people assume. Knowing how the claim is tested helps you use it sensibly.

What the word means

A comedone is a clogged hair follicle. DermNet describes two kinds: open comedones, or blackheads, and closed comedones, or whiteheads. A product described as comedogenic is one that can cause these plugs. Non-comedogenic means the product is intended not to.

The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) advises people with acne to look for makeup labeled "oil-free," "won't clog pores" or "non-comedogenic," and to look for the same wording on cleansers, hair products and skin care.

Why makeup can cause acne

The AAD uses the term acne cosmetica for acne triggered by cosmetics. It describes small bumps that usually appear on the cheeks, chin or forehead, and notes that lipstick or lip balm can cause breakouts around the lips. According to the AAD, this type of acne can take anywhere from days to six months to appear, which makes the cause hard to trace.

Hair products count too. DermNet describes pomade acne, a pattern of plugged follicles along the hairline linked to greasy styling products.

How it works: testing for comedogenicity

The rabbit ear assay

Early testing relied on animals. A 1984 paper in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology presented comedogenicity results for many products and ingredients from the rabbit ear assay. The authors acknowledged it was not an ideal model but described it as the best available at the time. Their working rule was that an ingredient testing negative in the assay could be considered safe for acne-prone skin, and that a strongly positive one should be avoided.

Lists of ingredients to avoid grew out of this kind of animal testing, as the 2006 study described below explains. A 2016 study in Skin Research and Technology notes that the rabbit ear model is useful in early product development but that a number of studies have found it overreacts to comedogenic materials.

Human testing

A 2017 paper in the Journal of Cosmetic Science describes two current approaches to supporting a non-comedogenic claim:

  • A human model first developed by Mills and Kligman and later modified. It is relatively inexpensive.
  • A human clinical trial, which is more costly and is considered the gold standard.

A 2006 study in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology shows what the human model looks like in practice. Six people with prominent pores and a known tendency to form comedones on the upper back had patches soaked in finished cosmetic products applied three times a week for four weeks. Researchers then used a surface biopsy technique with cyanoacrylate adhesive to count follicles and microcomedones.

The 2016 Skin Research and Technology study compared comedones on the face, chest and back in 66 women with mild to moderate acne. It recommended testing on both the back and the face, and noted that directly testing on the face can add reliability for milder ingredients and products.

Ingredient lists versus finished products

The 2006 study made an important point. Animal tests were originally run on raw materials, on the assumption that any finished product containing a flagged ingredient would also clog pores. That assumption led to lists of substances for acne-prone patients to avoid.

When the researchers tested finished products, they concluded that products made with comedogenic ingredients are not necessarily comedogenic themselves. The whole formula affects the result. The authors noted that only a limited number of products could be tested.

This is why judging a product only by checking its ingredient list against a comedogenic rating chart can be misleading.

Table 1. Ingredient lists versus finished products
Approach What it tests Main limitation
Rabbit ear assay Single ingredients or products on animal skin Reported to overreact to comedogenic materials
Human model (Mills and Kligman, modified) Products on the upper back under patches Small groups; back skin is not face skin
Human clinical trial Products used as intended More costly
Ingredient rating charts Single raw materials, often from older animal data Do not reflect the finished formula

How much do cosmetics matter?

Cosmetics may play a smaller role in adult acne than often assumed. A 2013 case-control study in Dermatology compared 910 people with post-adolescent acne to 910 matched controls. Overall cosmetic use was associated with lower odds of post-adolescent acne, and the association grew stronger with more cosmetic use. The authors still concluded that the term acne cosmetica is appropriate, because some cosmetics can cause acne.

This kind of study shows an association, not cause and effect. It does suggest that people with acne-prone skin do not need to avoid makeup as a rule. The AAD states directly that people with acne can wear makeup if they choose products that do not clog pores.

What the label does not tell you

A package rarely says which test, if any, supports its non-comedogenic claim. Skin-related label claims are not always tightly defined. The FDA, discussing the similar word "hypoallergenic," states that there are no federal standards or definitions governing that term and that manufacturers do not have to submit evidence for it. The FDA page does not address "non-comedogenic" specifically, but the example shows why such wording is best read as a manufacturer's claim.

Who should be careful

  • People with active acne. Even with careful product choices, acne often needs treatment. The AAD notes that over-the-counter salicylic acid, benzoyl peroxide and adapalene are options, and that improvement can take 4 to 8 weeks.
  • People with persistent breakouts. The AAD notes that foundation, blush, concealer and some hair and skin care products can all contribute, and that acne may have other causes. A dermatologist can help identify the trigger.
  • Shared makeup users. The AAD warns that sharing makeup or applicators can spread oil, dead skin cells and acne-causing bacteria, as well as contagious conditions such as pink eye and cold sores.

Practical steps

Use the label as a first filter

Choose products labeled non-comedogenic, oil-free or "won't clog pores," as the AAD suggests. Treat the claim as a reasonable starting point.

Test one product at a time

Because acne cosmetica can take days to months to appear, adding several new products at once makes it hard to tell which one is responsible.

Remove makeup every night

The AAD recommends removing all makeup, including eye makeup, before bed with an oil-free remover, followed by a gentle wash without scrubbing.

Keep tools clean

The AAD advises cleaning makeup brushes every week and not sharing them. It also suggests applying makeup with a light touch to avoid irritating the skin.

Wash gently

The AAD recommends washing the face twice a day and after sweating with a mild cleanser, using fingertips and lukewarm water.

The short version

"Non-comedogenic" means a product is meant not to clog pores. The claim may rest on older animal data, a small human patch test or a clinical trial, and the label rarely says which. Research shows that finished products can be non-comedogenic even when they contain an ingredient once flagged, so ingredient charts are a weak guide. Use the label as a first filter, introduce products one at a time, remove makeup nightly and see a dermatologist if breakouts persist.

References

  1. American Academy of Dermatology. I have acne! Is it okay to wear makeup? aad.org/public/diseases/acne/causes/makeup (opens in a new tab)
  2. DermNet. Acne vulgaris. dermnetnz.org/topics/acne-vulgaris (opens in a new tab)
  3. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology (via Europe PMC). A re-evaluation of the comedogenicity concept. europepmc.org/article/MED/16488305 (opens in a new tab)
  4. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology (via Europe PMC). Comedogenicity of current therapeutic products, cosmetics, and ingredients in the rabbit ear. europepmc.org/article/MED/6229554 (opens in a new tab)
  5. Skin Research and Technology (via Europe PMC). Analysis of comedone, sebum and porphyrin on the face and body for comedogenicity assay. europepmc.org/article/MED/26094640 (opens in a new tab)
  6. Journal of Cosmetic Science (via Europe PMC). Non-comedogenic and non-acnegenic claim substantiation. europepmc.org/article/MED/29616616 (opens in a new tab)
  7. Dermatology (via Europe PMC). Acne cosmetica revisited: a case-control study shows a dose-dependent inverse association between overall cosmetic use and post-adolescent acne. europepmc.org/article/MED/23859829 (opens in a new tab)
  8. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. "Hypoallergenic" Cosmetics. fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetics-labeling-claims/hypoallergenic-cosmetics (opens in a new tab)

Links go to the abstract, full text or reference page. Found an error? See corrections.